Shilo Sanders faces backlash after controversial comment toward reporter Mary Kay Cabot sparks criticism
TOI GLOBAL DESK | TOI GLOBAL | May 02, 2026, 02:03 IST
Shilo Sanders faces backlash after a controversial comment toward reporter Mary Kay Cabot sparks criticism
Shilo Sandersfaced backlash after making a controversial comment toward veteran reporterMary Kay Cabot, who covers theCleveland Browns. The incident began when Cabot reported thatShedeur Sanderswas not leading the quarterback competition and remained behindDeshaun Watson. In response, Shilo posted a remark widely viewed as sexist, drawing strong criticism online. Cabot later addressed the situation calmly during a radio appearance, choosing not to respond directly and instead highlighting her role as an inspiration for women in sports journalism. Shilo later defended his stance on a livestream, questioning her opinion but not her reporting facts. The moment sparked broader discussion about respect toward media members, especially women, while also bringing renewed attention to Cabot’s long and respected career covering the Browns.
Shilo Sanders sparked backlash after directing a controversial comment at veteran reporter Mary Kay Cabot, who covers the Cleveland Browns. The incident began after Cabot reported on the team’s quarterback situation, where she stated that Shedeur Sanders is not leading the competition for the starting role and is currently behind Deshaun Watson. She also gave her opinion that the Browns should name Watson as the starter soon so the offense can “start to cook” together.
Shilo reacted to that opinion on social media, replying, “Go make a sandwich Mary,” a phrase widely seen as sexist. The comment quickly drew criticism, especially given how common the phrase has been used to belittle women.
Cabot later addressed the situation during a radio appearance but chose to stay composed. She did not respond directly to Shilo and instead spoke about her impact as a woman in sports journalism. “I really do believe that I have been an inspiration for lots of women and young girls,” she said.
Shilo continued speaking about the issue on his Twitch stream, where he questioned her reporting and suggested she was being emotional in her coverage. He did not dispute her facts but disagreed with her opinions about the quarterback situation. “If you’re gonna be a reporter, be a reporter and report facts,” he said.
Cabot, who has covered the Browns since 1991, was honored by the Pro Football Writers Association for her long career.
Shilo reacted to that opinion on social media, replying, “Go make a sandwich Mary,” a phrase widely seen as sexist. The comment quickly drew criticism, especially given how common the phrase has been used to belittle women.
Cabot later addressed the situation during a radio appearance but chose to stay composed. She did not respond directly to Shilo and instead spoke about her impact as a woman in sports journalism. “I really do believe that I have been an inspiration for lots of women and young girls,” she said.
Shilo continued speaking about the issue on his Twitch stream, where he questioned her reporting and suggested she was being emotional in her coverage. He did not dispute her facts but disagreed with her opinions about the quarterback situation. “If you’re gonna be a reporter, be a reporter and report facts,” he said.
Cabot, who has covered the Browns since 1991, was honored by the Pro Football Writers Association for her long career.